FREE TRIAL VERSION. DON'T MISS OUT. |
FREE TRIAL VERSION. DON'T MISS OUT. |
|
|
It’s Time to Stop Worrying About Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries |
By David Corn November 15, 2025 |
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer speak at news conference in the Capitol on October 16. Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call via AP Images |
|
|
You're reading a free promotional version of Our Land, and we hope you enjoy David's exclusive writing and don't want to miss out on what's next. Sign up to start receiving a free 30-day trial of Our Land and enjoy all of the behind-the-scenes reports and interactive features with each issue.
|
|
|
“Are you the hostage negotiator?” “Yeah, tell me what we’ve got here.”
“We got a guy with three families in there, and he says he wants to blow up the house. And he’s on the line.”
“Gimme the phone…Hello, we know you’re holding three families and you’re threatening to blow up the house. What do you want?...Yeah, I know you want to blow up the house. Well, let’s see if we can avoid that and come up with a solution here…Yeah, okay, I hear you. You want to blow up the house. But that won’t be good for the people in the house. So let’s work something out…Okay, okay, what you want is to blow up the house. I know. But surely we can find a way to…I get it. You really, really, really want to blow up the house.”
|
|
|
Like many who have been pushing for the Democrats to more fiercely combat Donald Trump these past 10 months, I was not delighted to see seven Democratic senators and one independent cut a deal with the Republicans to end the government shutdown without obtaining what the Ds had been demanding: an extension of Obamacare subsidies to prevent skyrocketing health insurance premiums for millions. The Democrats had hung tight for six weeks and had largely succeeded in defining this battle as a showdown over the issue of health care. And polls indicated the public blamed Trump and the Republicans more than the Democrats for the shutdown. Those are not negligible accomplishments.
But the cave-in was not the worst of surrenders. The Democrats overall had been trying to force Trump and the GOP into a deal—extend the subsidies and we’ll vote to end the shutdown—that the Republicans were unlikely to ever accept. And what was their leverage? More shutdown pain? Americans families losing health care because of the premium hikes? But Trump and his handmaids in Congress don’t care about that. They don’t mind a closed government. Suspending food stamps doesn’t bother them. And they don’t want to revive subsidies for Obamacare. How do you negotiate with a hostage-taker who craves the destruction he threatens?
The Republicans would rather see Americans go hungry than bolster Obamacare. That’s the heart of the problem here.
Look at how Rep. James Comer, a Kentucky Republican, put it: "This is a fake economy. You can't have a third of America receiving some type of free government health care and then have another third that's getting a subsidized rate. That falls on the final third that's having to pay increased premiums." He and his fellow let-’em-eat-cake Republicans still want to annihilate Obamacare rather than extend its subsidies. They simply don’t believe Americans deserve this assistance in obtaining healthcare coverage. Had there been no deal, more Americans would have gone hungry and federal workers (including air traffic controllers and TSA screeners) would have had to keep working without receiving paychecks. Tough times would have gotten tougher for millions. Would that have put more pressure on the Rs? Perhaps. But possibly not. There would, though, have been a lot of damage.
It certainly would have been better for the party—especially after its stunning performance in the off-year elections—if this denouement had been orchestrated with more finesse as to avoid the revival of the all-too familiar Democrats-in-disarray theme. Internal bickering is a true drag for a party that needs to forge a popular front to beat back the forces of authoritarianism and kleptocracy that threaten American democracy. There may have been a way for the Ds to relent and declare victory. (Trump loses all the time and insists he’s the victor.) Instead, this finish united moderate and progressive Democrats, with both camps pissed off at the Exit Ramp Eight and many calling on Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer to move on.
This episode may offer a lesson for Democrats: Forget about Schumer and House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries (who was among those angry at the Acquiescing Eight). These guys are legislators, not national leaders, despite their titles. They are chosen by their respective caucuses. Their first responsibility is to serve their members—not the party at large or Democrats en masse—and that means doing whatever they can to get these guys and gals reelected. (Often that entails raising money.) Their second priority is striving to win or preserve a majority, which often involves supporting candidates at odds with the party on issues or other concerns. They need to herd cats that are often pursuing their own interests and to do so while engaged in legislative conflict with the other side. And then they are expected to lead the entire Democratic Party out of minority wilderness.
I’m not saying this pair ought not be criticized. But upset grassroots Democrats should understand what their jobs are. Fortunately for the Democrats, they don’t need this pair as crusading leaders. The recent elections, as I wrote last week, demonstrated that the party is brimming with effective banner carriers of different ideological stripes: Zohran Mamdani, Gavin Newsom, Abigail Spanberger, Mikie Sherrill, AOC, Bernie Sanders. They each have their own sets of responsibilities. Mamdani has to run the biggest city in America; Newsom has to oversee the fifth-largest economy in the world. But as we’ve seen in recent months, politicians who are chief executives of a state or city tend to be more effective and enthusiastic political street fighters than legislative leaders who are engaged in (or bogged down by) the combat and often complicated calculations of Capitol Hill.
Sure, a fierier Democratic leader in the Senate could be useful in this time of crisis. But that’s not what the Democratic caucus in the upper chamber seems to desire. I’m not a Schumer fan, but it’s hard to fault him for that. And he did not back the agreement reached by the We’re Outta Here Eight. They apparently did that on their own. Maybe a better and more persuasive (or more threatening) leader would have been able to prevent this bunch from breaking away. But maybe that’s a fantasy. So rather than kvetch, perhaps disappointed Democrats ought to lower expectations for Congress’ top Dems and turn toward other voices in the party for inspiration and kick-ass leadership.
Yet, in a way, the Escape the Shutdown Eight might have done the Democrats a favor. The political dynamics of this clash created a bizarre incentive structure. The Democrats, by pressing for the Obamacare subsidies, were essentially trying to help the Republicans save themselves from themselves.
Trump and the Republicans are in a jam of their own making. The ginormous ugly bill they passed this summer, with its slashes in Medicaid, will lead to 17 million or so Americans losing their health care. And they have taken no steps to address the premium crisis that has begun to hit millions of other Americans.
This is a tremendous liability for the GOP. Polls reflect that. Only 30 percent of Americans approve of how Trump is handling health care. Only 25 percent profess they trust Republicans on this front. About 40 percent say that for Democrats. And this is before all the premium hikes kick in. The Republicans have no plan to address any of this. Remember all the times Trump said he would kill Obamacare and deliver better and cheaper health care? He has never come up with a proposal. As the nation heads toward the midterms, this is a huge vulnerability for Republicans.
Had the Democrats managed to craft a budget agreement with the Republicans that extended the subsidies and averted a shutdown, this issue of exploding premiums would have been taken off the table. Mind you, I don’t believe the Rs would have ever agreed to such a deal. But those folks irate at the Turn Tail and Run Eight assumed that somehow more time would’ve led to the GOP folding on this point. In any event, that didn’t happen. Now Trump and the Republicans own the rising cost of health care insurance, and they have no clue what to do about it.
|
|
|
The Abdicate Eight were happy to declare that the deal they struck included a Senate vote in December on an extension of the subsidies. But it’s unlikely enough Republicans will vote for that. And House Speaker Mike Johnson—who was not a party to this accord—has not committed to such a vote in the House. That has provided the House Democrats an opening, and (before I could suggest this) they have wisely declared they will proceed with a discharge petition to force a vote on reviving the subsidies. This could put a lot of pressure of Rs in swing districts. Whatever happens in both houses in the coming months, a good guess is that in 2026, the Ds will be able to stick it to the Rs on health care—a potent issue in state and local elections—and boost their chances of winning the House and maybe even the Senate. And keep this in mind: the deal just struck funds the government only through the end of January. We could be at this again early next year.
At first glance, it looks like a handful of Democrats wussed out and undermined what had been a united stand within their party against Trump and his GOP cult. And they did. But there may be a mammoth silver lining to this cloud. Thus, Democrats ought to quit the moaning and the griping that makes it seem they are once again divided and adrift. In politics, there are good losses and bad losses, and smart politicians can turn a good loss to their advantage. This shutdown showdown, regardless of its conclusion, has well positioned the Democrats, as long as they keep fighting Trump and his minions and not themselves.
Got anything to say about this item—or anything else? Email me at ourland.corn@gmail.com. |
The Next Our Land Zoom Get-Together
|
I know. It’s been a while. This has been a busy stretch with multiple outrages happening every day. But before holiday season craziness strikes, let’s gather for another Our Land Zoom shindig on November 25 at 8:00 p.m. ET. We can help you prepare for Thanksgiving dinner with that relative you don’t want to talk politics with.
As most of you know, these sessions are only open to premium subscribers, that noble band of folks who pay a few bucks a month to get the full version of this newsletter, which includes an assortment of features: extra behind-the-scenes reports, Dumbass Comment of the Week, Inspiration of the Week, the interactive Mailbag (you send in questions, I reply), MoxieCam™, and reviews of movies, books, music, television shows, podcasts, and other cultural fare.
In addition to receiving this content, premium subscribers have the satisfaction of knowing they are keeping this enterprise afloat. Without their financial support, we couldn’t keep the lights on. So even if you don’t want all these other features but value this newsletter, please consider subscribing so we can continue to deliver kick-ass reporting and analysis in these difficult days. (I won’t bore you with talk of “churn” and the need to add subscribers to sustain this operation.) You can sign up here.
As for the Zoom get-together, the day of the event, premium subscribers will receive a Zoom invitation. Just click on that, and our bouncers—who used to be security guards at the Louvre—will let you in. See you soon. |
|
|
Dumbass Comment of the Week |
It was a tough week for Trump lovers, as thousands of Jeffrey Epstein documents were released, reminding the world that Trump had once been close pals with this cretin and that perhaps he’s been covering up something untoward regarding his relationship with the criminal pedophile and sex trafficker. This was big news. Yet here’s how Fox host Laura Ingraham opened her show on the day these Epstein files were released: |
Nothing to see. But hip, hip, hooray for that Trump interview. Alex Jones’ bonkers conspiracy theory site had this take: |
Twenty-three thousand pages of material were released. That’s hardly cherry-picking. None provided evidence that Trump participated in the sexual abuse of girls. But several raised questions about Trump’s interactions with Epstein and what he knew of Epstein’s foul and criminal conduct.
Right-wing commentator and Trump champion Megyn Kelly had one of the most bizarre comments regarding Epstein this week: "I know somebody very close to this case…Jeffrey Epstein, in this person's view, was not a pedophile…He was into the barely legal type, like he liked 15-year-old girls…He wasn't into like 8-year-olds…There's a difference between a 15-year-old and a 5-year-old.” |
Imagine making this stand: 15 is “barely legal”? The age of consent in Florida is 18. Fifteen is far from that—and it’s rather far from adulthood. (Speaking of which, did you see this Matt Gaetz story?)
The judges thought that Argentina President Javier Milei deserved an honorable mention for a dumb dance he performed at a Conservative Political Action Conference gala at Mar-a-Lago. |
Given that Milei was dancing to celebrate the $20 billion bail-out Trump provided him, perhaps there should have been a pole. Speaking of Ingraham’s interview with Trump—which he loved!—during that chat, he proposed essentially replacing the Affordable Care Act with a privatized system:
What I want is instead of going to the insurance companies, I want the money to go into an account for people where the people buy their own health insurance. It's so good. The insurance will be better. It'll cost less. Everybody is gonna be happy. They're gonna feel like entrepreneurs. They're actually able to go out and negotiate their own health insurance…Call it Trumpcare. |
There’s much wrong with this idea, which right-wingers have been pushing for years. But Trumpcare? Reminds us of Trump University. Or the Trump Taj Mahal? Or Trump Steaks. While Trump was being fed softball questions from Ingraham, she asked him whether affordability is a real issue, wondering if it was merely “voter perception.” Trump replied:
More than anything else, it’s a con job by the Democrats. They just have to say, they put out something: Say today that costs are up. They feed it to the anchors of ABC, CBS, and NBC, and a lot of other, and CNN, etc., and it’s like a standard—I’ll never forget they had to use the word like “manufacture.” You remember the word “manufacture”? “It’s a manufactured economy.” Nobody uses that word. Every anchor broke—the “manufactured.” They do exactly what they say. It’s such a rigged system. So are you ready. Costs are way down. Gasoline is going to be hitting $2.00 pretty soon or around $2.00. Gasoline is at $2.70 now. It was at $4.50 under Biden.
|
Trump was barely coherent in his response. But he was pushing yet another conspiracy theory: Democrats routinely develop an anti-Trump economic message, pass it to the network news shows, and the anchors robotically transmit this talking point. His evidence? They used the word “manufacture.” This is nuts. If Trump truly believes this, he is off his rocker. By the way, the average price for a gallon of gas this week is not the $2.70 Trump stated but $3.07. Ingraham did not correct him. If Trump doesn’t stick to economic facts, there’s no reason why his top economic adviser should. When Kevin Hassett, the director of Trump’s National Economic Council, was asked by CNBC host Carl Quintanilla about inflation, he either misled the public or showed he doesn’t know basic facts: Hassett: We're comfortable that inflation has come way down…and the trajectory is really, really, really good.
Quintanilla: Even though it's been increasing for five straight months as of September? Hassett: There’s ups and downs and seasonals. |
Seems as if the top economics guy at the White House can’t read a bar chart.
In a highly competitive week, Eric Trump elbowed his way into the winner’s circle. When he’s not tending to his families crypto-grift business, he’s been promoting his new book Under Siege. Pushing this volume, he appeared on MAGA influencer Benny Johnson’s show and declared, “We're saving Christianity. We're saving God…We have a return to people going to church. We have a return to people valuing their children.” |
Prior to Trump’s return to the White House, people didn’t value their children? Amazing that we survived as a species. But it’s rather hubristic for young Trump to proclaim that he and his family are “saving God.” It’s almost as if the Trumps have a God complex. |
|
|
Resistance comes in many forms. This week, the Washington National Opera announced it was considering moving out of the Kennedy Center, its home since 1971. Francesca Zambello, the outfit’s artistic director, explained this was because of Trump’s “takeover’ of the cultural center. Trump’s move, she said, “shattered” donor confidence and led to a precipitous 40-percent drop in ticket sales.
Many opera loves are boycotting the Kennedy Center, and Zambello tells the Guardian that she receives messages of protests every day from former patrons: “They say things like: ‘I’m never setting foot in there until the orange menace is gone.’ Or: ‘Don’t you know history? Don’t you know what Hitler did? I refuse to give you a penny.’ People send me back the season brochure shredded in an envelope and say: ‘Never, never, will I return, while he’s in power.’”
Opera aficionados are voting with their ears…and their pocketbooks. |
Write about the Democrats and their ups or downs, and the mail pours in. Readers have thoughts. Rusty Curling emailed:
Pretty much agree with what you said about a big-tent Democratic Party. If the Democrats can pull that off, they will rule America for decades to come. And we will certainly be better off than having authoritarians like Trump and the current butt sniffers in the Republican party. I would remind you that it is not the left who has pushed the center away, but the other way around. I have left the Democratic Party because the leadership of the party made it perfectly clear that I (a leftist, Democratic socialist) have no place in the party. They want my vote, but leave my ideas at the door thank you.
That the current leadership of the party did not endorse Mamdani and even worked to elect his disgraced opponent, is a testament to this. They marginalize anyone that strays "too far" to the left, which means anyone that threatens their relationship with their group of corporate and billionaire doners. So, anyone who doesn't accept that money and especially anyone who makes a campaign issue of it in the primaries is automatically marginalized. When the party leadership breaks the chains of corporate money they are bound up in, I will consider coming back. Until then, expect the leaders of the party to marginalize Mamdani, AOC, Bernie and anyone who steps too far from the center right that the party really is... and watch them attempt to undermine Mamdani at every opportunity. But we can keep hoping for a real reform of the Democratic party. I'm not holding my breath though. Robert Edwards emailed: Excellent piece on the faux controversy within the Democratic Party over whether its future is Mamdani or Sherrill. We are our own worst enemy on matters like that. But the right-wing also loves to gaslight us into non-crises of this sort.
Eileen McInerney was appreciative of my advocacy for Warren Zevon’s induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, which recently occurred:
I am so happy to hear they are admitting Warren Zevon to the Hall of Fame. I’ve been a big fan since the 70s. I saw him perform at My Father’s Place in Roslyn, New York, in 1978. When the band began playing “Werewolves of London,” someone in a gorilla/bear suit started dancing in front of the band. I thought it was part of the act, though I found out afterward it was a fan who dressed up and Warren let him do his thing.
Lee Carlin had a question after reading the issue on the right’s long-term relationship with Nazis: How does this lineage of Nazi alliances fit with the Trump administration demanding an investigation of antisemitism on “elite liberal campuses”?
I don't believe Trump and his cronies really care about antisemitism or see it as a crisis. They are exploiting it as a weapon to use against what they consider bastions of liberalism and "wokeness": elite universities. It's a cynical ploy. |
“Moxie, isn’t it great to be out in nature?” “What’s nature?” “Well, it’s the outdoors. Trees, fields, a creek, fresh air. Isn’t it special?”
“Seems normal to me. Isn’t this where we should be all the time?” “Yes, but then you’d have no scrambled eggs.” “Good point. When are we going home?” |
|
|
Congratulations, you read all the way to the end! It's a great time to say "I'm in" and start your free 30-day trial. Make sure you don't miss out on what's next: Sign up to start getting Our Land in your inbox each week. We also want to hear from readers (especially those who read the whole thing!). So let us know what you think so far or share something interesting with David at ourland.corn@gmail.com.
|
|
|
|